Celebrities

Retail Discounts Prompt Half of Shoppers to Use False or Secondary Contact Details

2026-11-04 16:38
904 views

Cloaked’s survey finds privacy and spam concerns are pushing shoppers to mask their contact details when seeking retail promotions.

Retailers may be collecting less useful customer data than their sign-up forms suggest. A Cloaked survey of more than 1,000 consumers found that 51 percent of U.S. shoppers withhold their real phone number or email when registering for retail discounts, coupons or promotions. For brands counting on those details to build customer relationships, the incentive itself can deepen distrust. A discount can bring someone to a form, but it doesn’t guarantee that the information they enter will help a retailer reach them again.

Privacy and spam drive shoppers to mask details

The survey points to a broad reluctance to share personal contact information: 89 percent of respondents said they avoid giving their real number or email in at least one everyday situation, and 97 percent cited at least one reason for doing so. Avoiding spam and unwanted marketing led the list at 91 percent, followed by concerns about scams or fraud at 79 percent and data privacy at 65 percent. These reasons overlap, but together they describe a practical calculation: a small immediate benefit may not justify giving a business a lasting route to a person’s inbox or phone.

Those concerns shape how consumers approach retail offers. Among shoppers who withhold their details when signing up for promotions, 65 percent said they were worried about data breaches or the sale, sharing or cross-account tracking of their information. Separately, 61 percent of respondents said they use a secondary email address instead of their primary one. And 71 percent regretted having previously given businesses or online platforms their real phone number. That regret matters because it suggests some shoppers see disclosure as a decision that’s difficult to reverse once their details start circulating.

Exposure is already familiar to many respondents: 55 percent said their phone number or email address had appeared in a known data breach. The survey also found that 91 percent withhold contact details to avoid unwanted messages, underscoring how directly marketing fatigue shapes sign-up behavior. The numbers here are underwhelming for any retailer hoping that a required field signals genuine interest. A completed form may record a transaction, while the customer’s actual intent is simply to get through the offer without exposing a primary address.

Long-held contact details carry a lasting cost

Americans in the survey had kept the same phone number for an average of 12 years and the same email address for 14. That continuity makes those details useful for reaching customers, but it also leaves them exposed over time. A contact address can persist through many separate sign-ups, which means an old choice may keep shaping what messages reach someone long after the original exchange. The report said people with primary phone numbers held for more than a decade receive 45 percent more spam texts, robocalls and scam attempts than people with newer numbers. Long-held email addresses receive 88 percent more, according to the report.

Those comparisons don’t establish why the messages accumulate, or whether a long-held address itself causes the difference. They do point to a cost that consumers associate with keeping the same contact details in circulation. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A retailer asking for a phone number isn’t asking only for a way to send a receipt or promotion; it’s asking for access to an identifier that may already be used across years of online activity.

Responses also differed by device platform. Android users were more likely than iPhone users to cite data privacy as a reason to withhold their real contact details, at 68 percent versus 61 percent. They were also more likely to report receiving wrong-number calls or texts, at 41 percent versus 36 percent. The survey identifies a difference between groups, but it doesn’t explain what drives it, so the figures are best read as a description of respondents’ reported experiences rather than evidence that a device platform causes them.

More required data can mean weaker customer records

Retailers are entering the holiday shopping season with AI increasingly shaping product discovery and shopping. Yet, as Cloaked’s researchers put it, “The push for higher conversions is colliding with shoppers’ growing concerns about fraud, security and unwanted marketing.” Asking for a phone number or email to unlock a discount may add friction at precisely the moment a shopper is weighing whether a brand deserves access. That tension is sharper when the benefit is immediate but the future use of the data is vague.

There’s a practical cost, too. When shoppers substitute secondary addresses or inaccurate numbers, retailers can end up with records that are harder to reach and less useful for marketing. The report’s findings suggest that collection forms built around permanent contact details may undermine the customer data quality they’re meant to improve. More fields can create the appearance of richer records without giving a business a reliable way to understand or contact the person behind them.

For a retailer, that makes the wording and design of a sign-up form part of the customer relationship. If you’re working in this space, the question isn’t just whether a required field lifts sign-ups; it’s whether customers will trust the exchange enough to provide details they actually check. A smaller request, paired with a clear explanation, may produce more meaningful information than a form that treats every contact detail as a condition of entry.

Trust will shape the value of a discount

Consumers are responding to digital exposure by separating their primary details from routine sign-ups, using aliases and seeking removal of personal data. Retailers can treat those habits as a signal about what shoppers expect: control over which details they share, and a clear account of what happens next. That’s a more demanding standard than simply offering a coupon, but it follows directly from the concerns the survey records.

The takeaway is to make the exchange clearer: explain how contact details will be used, reduce what’s required to claim an offer and give customers a reason to share information. Here’s the thing: collecting less can be the more useful choice if it leaves a retailer with information customers are willing to keep using. Trust may determine whether a discount earns a relationship—or just another disposable email address.

Or a phone number entered only to get past the form. That’s the gap retailers have to close.

Source: Arthur Zaczkiewicz · wwd.com