Apparel groups warn proposed port fees could raise supply chain costs, reduce U.S. fashion exports and threaten jobs across the industry.
USFIA says the proposed port fees could put jobs across the apparel industry at risk. Justin Sullivan/Getty ImagesFees could ripple well beyond shipping
A policy aimed at China’s shipbuilding industry could hit U.S. apparel businesses too. The United States Fashion Industry Association (
USFIA) told the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative (
USTR) that U.S.
apparel exports could fall 5 percent if Section 301 fees on Chinese-linked ships take effect.
USFIA, the American Apparel and Footwear Association (
AAFA) and the National Retail Federation (
NRF) backed USTR’s
proposal to extend the fee suspension by two months. The groups had also supported the office’s earlier positions on trade and the fees, including in coverage of
USFIA and AAFA’s trade concerns and the
USTR’s Section 301 work.
The proposed surcharges would apply when Chinese-built or Chinese-operated vessels call at U.S.
ports. Similar fees briefly took effect in October and November before the U.S. and China
paused them and then
postponed them for a year as trade tensions eased.
The associations say a short extension leaves businesses planning around a moving deadline. If adopted, the latest proposal would push the pause to Jan. 9, 2027. They argue the fees could raise costs throughout supply chains and complicate logistics, while doing little in the near term to rebuild U.S. shipbuilding.
USFIA put a number on the potential domestic impact: a 4 percent decline in U.S. fashion and apparel employment and output. That estimate comes from a March 2025 economic study by Trade Partnership Worldwide. The association also cited Moongate Associates’ estimate that 70 percent of the value of an imported garment supports U.S. jobs in design, sourcing, distribution, retail and services.
That’s a useful reminder that an import’s price tag doesn’t tell you where its economic value goes. USFIA president Julia Hughes said each proposed remedy could harm the U.S. economy, whether introduced alone or in combination, by raising costs and reducing sales and employment in wholesale and retail.
Hughes also warned that U.S.-made inputs underpin the
Western Hemisphere supply chain. If new shipping charges disrupt those flows, she argued, those inputs could become less competitive. In a letter to USTR, she said higher labor and transportation expenses can increase clothing production costs, which manufacturers may pass on to consumers through higher prices. That could weaken spending, sales and fashion retail employment.
Retailers and carriers want a longer pause
The comment period on USTR’s extension proposal closed last Friday, with 64 submissions filed. The agency has yet to issue a final decision. Without one, the existing suspension is due to expire at 11:59 p.m. Eastern time on Nov. 9.
AAFA, which represents more than 1,100 brands and more than $561 billion in annual U.S. retail sales, urged USTR to settle the issue for the longer term and announce its decision promptly. Its earlier comments on
apparel prices and inflation reflect the same concern: extra costs can reach consumers.
AAFA trade and transportation manager Audrey Clark said the fees haven’t shown meaningful progress toward strengthening U.S. shipbuilding. She argued that carriers instead moved non-Chinese-built vessels onto U.S. routes while continuing to place orders at Chinese shipyards. Chinese carriers, she added, shifted some calls to Canada and Mexico to avoid the charges, diverting business from U.S.
ports and workers.
The proposed extension would prolong uncertainty for apparel, travel goods and footwear companies, Clark said. Their supply chains depend on shipping contracts made well in advance, seasonal production calendars and complex transport networks. AAFA members generally don’t choose which vessels carry their cargo, she said, leaving them exposed when fees or routes change suddenly.
Clark also pointed to tariffs on ship-to-shore cranes and cargo-handling equipment, arguing that limited alternative suppliers could make port upgrades more expensive. The association favors investment and partnerships with allies; one example is South Korean shipbuilder Hanwha’s announced
$5 billion investment in Philadelphia’s shipyard.
NRF also called for a substantially longer suspension, or removal of the fees, while negotiations with China continue. The group said retailers and importers make shipping and routing decisions months before cargo leaves overseas. NRF executive vice president for government relations David French warned that the uncertainty makes it harder to forecast demand, reserve transport capacity, negotiate rates and plan inventory. It could also constrain capacity and add volatility to ocean shipping prices.
The shipping industry has its own concerns. The World Shipping Council, which represents ocean carriers, urged a permanent pause. It argued that retroactive fees on ships already built or ordered would penalize earlier business decisions without reducing dependence on Chinese shipbuilding. Hapag-Lloyd’s U.S. subsidiary told USTR officials on Friday that the agency could instead encourage cargo to move on U.S.-flagged vessels.
Manufacturing groups oppose extending the pause
The split is sharp: apparel groups and carriers see the fees as a cost and planning problem, while some manufacturing and labor organizations view them as pressure on China’s maritime industry. The Alliance for American Manufacturing (AAM) and United Steelworkers (USW) were among the few commenters opposing a suspension. They argued that Chinese subsidies, non-market practices and predatory pricing continue to damage U.S. maritime businesses.
AAM president Scott Paul said the notice gave no indication that those practices had been eliminated or meaningfully addressed. He warned that extending the pause would prolong uncertainty for shipyards, suppliers, carriers, workers and investors, while delaying the market signal the fees were meant to create.
USW led the five-union coalition that filed the original
Section 301 complaint. That complaint prompted USTR’s nine-month investigation into China’s influence in maritime, logistics and shipbuilding.
The disagreement is about more than whether the fees work. It’s also about who bears the cost while the U.S. tries to rebuild a strategic industry—and whether a temporary pause gives businesses needed certainty or delays pressure on Chinese shipbuilding.
Related stories
Sign up for the SJ Daily Newsletter and special offers