Music

Charlie Kaplan’s Dobro Finds Humor and Hurt in Acoustic Songs

2026-10-30 15:00
449 views

On Dobro, Charlie Kaplan pairs dry humor and stripped-back folk with songs about anger, depression and the possibility of starting over.

Charlie Kaplan. (Credit: Julian Master)
Charlie Kaplan’s Dobro Hymn

Charlie Kaplan’s fifth album, Dobro, sounds casual on the surface: mostly acoustic arrangements, rough-edged production and jokes that can turn on a rhyme. Underneath, the songs keep reaching for something more exposed. Kaplan, the New York singer-songwriter and former member of indie sophisti-poppers Office Culture, writes about flawed characters whose punchlines don’t quite hide the hurt.

“Chemical Reaction” makes that tension plain. Kaplan says he wrote it to clear his head after a particularly strong drink. Its narrator, though, has little interest in learning from a bad night. “So yeah that’s when I started drinking / And then I had a couple more / I forgot to have some water / The second I walked in the door,” he sings in a light, bemused baritone.

A loose taproom melody, skittering palm-muted guitar and ragged backing vocals give the account an easygoing bounce. Kaplan’s wry emphasis on “water” makes the narrator’s mistake sound obvious—and likely to happen again. After a rough trip home on the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, the character ends up sick in bed, promising, “tomorrow I’ll be a brand-new me.”

The vow gets a sly sendoff. A sustained backing-vocal note and organ drone lend the ending a churchlike glow, as if the narrator has found religion in the aftermath. There’s a joke in that turn, but the plaintive sound leaves open the possibility that the hope is real, too.

That mix of comic detail and genuine frustration runs through Dobro. On the Roger Miller-esque title track, Kaplan rhymes “dobro” with “old bro”; “Failed” pairs “hoi polloi” with “Siegfried & Roy.” But “Failed” isn’t just a string of odd references. Its bright, jangling list of people and institutions that have let him down—from “Jake at State Farm” to “Peyton Manning’s chicken parm”—builds toward a sharp expression of anger.

The song’s joke about the late Las Vegas performers becomes an unexpectedly apt image of exhaustion. Kaplan identifies with the tiger that mauled one of them onstage, singing, “Between the leather whip and the flaming hoop / You can’t see how you’ll take another day.” The jaunty arrangement doesn’t soften the line so much as make its despair hit from an unexpected angle.

“Sick of You” uses a similar mismatch. Lyrics about depression ride a cheerful shuffle, driven by Justin Cubillos’s rolling bass and lively percussion from Jason Burger, Kaplan’s Office Culture collaborator. The closing passage then changes the song’s meaning: “But you only learn if you live / that’s why you gotta stay alive,” Kaplan sings over bright keys, before adding, “I want you to stay alive.” The refrain turns the title into something less like rejection than a confession from someone who still cares.

Office Culture leader Winston Cook-Wilson and collaborator Nate Mendelsohn also appear on the album; Andrew Daly Frank contributes guitar. Their presence connects Dobro to Kaplan’s musical circle, while its stripped-down sound puts his writing in the foreground.

Earlier records leaned more directly on autobiography and wore their influences more openly. “Halley,” from last year’s A Hat Upon the Bed, carries traces of Pavement and the Pixies, while Elliott Smith’s influence lingers elsewhere. On Dobro, Kaplan mostly writes through characters. The distance doesn’t make the songs feel less personal; if anything, the humor and bruised tenderness make it harder to tell where the narrator ends and Kaplan begins.

More from Spin:

To see our running list of the top 100 greatest rock stars of all time, click here.

Source: Reed Jackson · www.spinmagazine.com