Movies

The Testament of Ann Lee: A Worthwhile Follow-Up to You Can See Everything

2026-10-24 22:00
417 views

Amanda Seyfried anchors You Can See Everything, while her 2025 film The Testament of Ann Lee offers another striking showcase for her and Christopher Abbott.

This piece contains full spoilers for “You Can See Everything.” Stop here if you haven’t watched the documentary.

The sharpest turn in Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder’s A24 documentary “You Can See Everything” comes when Amanda Seyfried joins the story. Her arrival transforms a film about Elizabeth Holmes and the Theranos fraud into a stranger, more self-aware examination of how people make sense of a notorious public figure. It also offers a good reason to seek out “The Testament of Ann Lee,” the underseen 2025 drama starring Seyfried and Christopher Abbott.

For roughly its first 90 minutes, “You Can See Everything” follows Holmes as she prepares to begin an 11-year prison sentence for defrauding Theranos investors with its faulty blood-testing machine. Fielder, who appears on camera as an interviewer and guide, tracks Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans. The film’s unusual premise is clear, but its direction becomes less so after Holmes goes to prison.

Then Fielder plays his footage for Seyfried. The actor portrayed Holmes in Liz Meriwether’s Hulu series “The Dropout,” and she becomes a thoughtful audience for Fielder’s attempt to understand the former Theranos executive. Seyfried also acts out scenes the documentary couldn’t film or show, with Abbott stepping in as Evans.

That casting creates an unexpected link to “The Testament of Ann Lee.” Seyfried and Abbott share the screen in Mona Fastvold’s drama, though the available details don’t establish whether the film led to Abbott’s casting in Fielder’s documentary. The overlap is a curious coincidence either way.

The Testament of Ann Lee gives Seyfried and Abbott very different roles

Fastvold’s film centers on Ann Lee, the historical religious leader associated with the founding of the Shaker movement. Seyfried plays Lee as a woman whose religious conviction deepens after she joins the “Shaking Quakers,” whose worship includes dance, and loses all her children in infancy.

Abbott plays Abraham Standerin, Lee’s husband. Their marriage breaks down over his interest in sex, which Lee regards as sinful. She eventually leaves him to preach the Shaker faith and its commitment to celibacy. Abbott’s part is smaller than Seyfried’s, but their roles give the actors a markedly different dynamic from their brief pairing as Holmes and Evans in the documentary’s staged sequences.

“The Testament of Ann Lee” wrapped filming in December 2024. A title card in “You Can See Everything” says its second section was filmed two years after the first, which dates to 2023. Those details make the actors’ overlap intriguing, but they don’t confirm how Abbott came to join the documentary.

Seyfried is the documentary’s most revealing presence

Seyfried’s contribution is more than a performance. She questions whether Fielder can stay impartial, while her distance from Holmes gives her room to assess the subject without the baggage of a personal relationship. She has never met Holmes, and that separation makes her a useful counterweight to Fielder’s inquiry.

Her role also complicates the usual categories around documentary acting. Seyfried has an Academy Award nomination for supporting actress for “Mank,” but the Academy has never nominated an actor for work in a documentary. “You Can See Everything” sits in an unusual space: Seyfried plays a version of herself, reflects on a real person, and performs scenes alongside Fielder’s nonfiction material.

That hybrid approach makes her the film’s anchor. Abbott helps complete the re-enactments, but Seyfried is the one who pushes Fielder’s investigation into more reflective territory. The documentary’s late shift may be disorienting; her presence is what gives it focus.

For viewers drawn to Seyfried’s work in “You Can See Everything,” “The Testament of Ann Lee” is a natural next watch. It pairs her with Abbott in a historical drama that gives their screen connection a very different context. The film is available to stream on Hulu.

Source: [email protected] (Nina Starner) · www.slashfilm.com