The Hollywood Reporter had a seat inside the season two finale of SNL UK on Saturday. The interesting question by this point isn’t whether Britain’s version of an American institution can work. It’s how deliberately British the show can be while still borrowing that institution’s machinery.
At Television Centre, the machinery is everywhere. Hundreds of people spend the two-month season working on the show; the building feels less like a studio than a university campus in the final week of term. A busy food hall, nervous embraces and a band rehearsing behind the walls set the scene. Then there’s the security, unusually tight even by television standards. At 9 p.m., with airtime approaching, the place hums with the sense that the team still has something to prove.
That pressure has some context. The Sky series opened earlier this year with solid viewing figures and Tina Fey as host. Her first episode drew more than 220,000 viewers in Britain. The season fell away sharply by the end: Ncuti Gatwa’s finale, scheduled against the Eurovision Song Contest, reached a series low of 86,420. Critics, though, were generally receptive.
Season two began with another American star. Jeff Goldblum hosted on Sept. 9, with CMAT as musical guest, and drew an overnight audience of 105,000. The next four hosts were more recognizably British names: Jamie Demetriou, Amelia Dimoldenberg, Danny Dyer and James Norton. At the finale, the audience included Gatwa, Ike Barinholtz, Lizzy Caplan, Demetriou and Dimoldenberg. Onstage was Cynthia Erivo, the Wicked star. A member of the hair and makeup team called her a standout host on the way to the set; the cast and crew, it seems, have taken to her.
The returning cast is a deep bench of U.K. comedy talent: Hammed Animashaun, Al Nash, Ayoade Bamgboye, Larry Dean, Celeste Dring, George Fouracres, Annabel Marlow, Jack Shep and Emma Sidi. Weekend Update anchors Ania Magliano and Paddy Young have had a particularly good year; both sold out solo runs at the Edinburgh Fringe in August. Freddie Meredith, from Such Brave Girls, is the season’s only new cast member. In Saturday’s episode, he plays Prince William on The Graham Norton Show. Shep, bearded and speaking with an Irish accent, asks whether William’s brother Harry has been in touch that week. “Shut up!” Meredith replies, flashing the prince’s familiar teeth-baring grin.
Two seasons in, the familiar objection remains: will a format born on American television make British audiences laugh? Yes. But the jokes make the case through local detail, and sometimes through references that may leave even the visiting American stars Barinholtz and Caplan guessing. There’s Noel Fielding’s peculiar posture on The Great British Bake Off, a Walthamstow wedding interrupted by a rapper still feuding with Thames Water, and a princess in a tower who throws a can of Lilt at her would-be rescuer. The show knows whom it’s talking to. That specificity is its point.
The live audience numbers 275. Each week, the cast and writers bring 30 to 40 sketches to a read-through; by the 6 p.m. dress rehearsal on Saturday, only six or seven remain. The show goes live four hours later. Dress rehearsal is where the fine adjustments happen, down to moving a cue card a centimetre to the left. Live comedy looks loose when it works. The preparation is anything but.
Still, the room has the feel of a party. There are cameras, bright lights and an “APPLAUSE” sign above the bleachers, but the cast works to get the audience on its side. Animashaun and Nash jump onstage for an impromptu duet in a set dressed like a smoky Soho basement club. The crowd is urged to cheer, dance and enjoy the strange thrill of watching television being made in real time.
The cold open starts with Fouracres as Andy Burnham on Celebrity Gogglebox, followed by Dring’s Claudia Winkleman taking a swipe at the dullness of this season’s Celebrity Traitors. Then Erivo gets her monologue. She addresses the impression left by the famously intense Wicked press tour: she’s not as serious as people think. A slideshow of her deadpan face pasted onto a skydiver helps make the point. “I love the feeling of the wind through my… nails,” she says.
Her nails become the joke. “To me, they’re normal. I’ve had them since I was 16,” Erivo says. “They’re an extension of my body, an expression of my soul, and surprisingly practical. I haven’t had to use cutlery in years.” Then she imagines bringing them to The Great British Bake Off: “Making cake batter with one nail, chopping my butter with the other. Noel’s telling me I’ve got 30 seconds left, and Alison [Hammond] just keeps laughing. It’s not funny, Hammond. Seriously, what are you laughing at? I’ve got a soggy bottom, and I’m freaking stressed!”
Erivo carries that ease into the sketches. In one, she’s a hitwoman trying to empty an awkward B&B breakfast room by pretending to love birds, complete with bird calls. In “Modern Music,” she and Marlow parody the way female rappers sing about their bodies. Erivo’s character calls hers “gorgeous, stunning, clever and it’s somehow always clean,” before singing, “It sings just like an angel, it shines just like the sun, it doesn’t really take much if you want to make me… dance.” Marlow’s character is less sure of the subject: “It’s not that mine’s bad, I just don’t know what a good one is!”
The biggest reaction belongs to “Nigerian Wicked,” a sapphic Nollywood spin on the role that made Erivo a star. She plays Glinda opposite Bamgboye’s Elphaba. The effects are deliberately rough, the narration gloriously overwrought — “Glinda doesn’t like egg, so their relationship is very strained” — and the audience is soon laughing hard. The pair head down the Yellow Brick Road to find the Wizard of LagOz, played by Animashaun. Glinda promises Elphaba a “gravity-defying” BBL; when they reach the Wizard, he’s broke. “That’s a nolex!” Erivo exclaims. The credits give her full name: Cynthia Chinasaokwu Onyedinmanasu Owezuke Amarachukwu Echimino Erivo.
The sketch also shows that the show understands how its audience finds comedy now. “Nigerian Wicked” passed one million YouTube views in less than 24 hours. That’s a striking early result for a single sketch, though it doesn’t tell us how many viewers are watching the broadcast itself. The show’s online reach is becoming part of the story.
A live show that looks comfortable in its own skin
The jokes are still the draw. On Weekend Update, Magliano and Young deliver the show’s sharpest satire: Young opens with a gag about Meghan Markle’s father being accused of being an alleged pedophile, framing it as another bid to win over the British public. Young also auditions for James Bond, while Shep drops in as Scrimpch, his moustached character with the exaggerated accent.
But the room’s energy says as much about the production as the punchlines. Five or six sets ring the cast and crew, who shift between them during four-minute ad breaks, with live jazz keeping the audience engaged. Blossoms play twice and look at ease. Cast members race between costumes and wigs, then turn back to wave, dance and greet one another. After the finale, Cynthia Erivo keeps hugging the cast even after the cameras stop. The connection feels real, and it gives the polished production a sense of warmth.
SNL UK season three is scheduled for January. That doesn’t guarantee the show has solved every creative challenge, but this performance makes a persuasive case that it has found its footing: the staging runs smoothly, the cast seems settled, and the room feels alive. If that chemistry holds, the next series has a solid base to build on.