A surgeon's confession
Some sentences in a phone call stop you cold. For Jamie D Brooks, one came in spring 2020, when a trauma surgeon admitted he'd operated on the wrong kidney. The surgeon's voice was stripped raw, the way a voice gets after years of delivering bad news. Brooks, who ran risk management for a 700-clinician teaching hospital near Washington, DC, recognized the category immediately. He had just described a Never Event.
The moment is the opening of Brooks's memoir,
The Fleeing Season, and it sets up everything that follows: a hospital, a family, and a country that all seemed to be failing at once.
What a Never Event actually is
The name is aspirational. Never Events should never happen, and yet they happen a lot more often than the label implies. Hospitals save lives every day, but they're also dangerous places, and the danger is partly hidden. Whether and how Never Events get reported varies, and nondisclosure provisions in malpractice settlements keep some cases out of view. Brooks points to a figure that should stop anyone cold: iatrogenic death, meaning death caused by medical activity, ranks as the third leading cause of death in the United States.
The term itself is more recent than many people assume. Physician Ken Kizer coined "Never Event" in 2001, and the medical community soon settled on a working definition: serious, preventable errors that often result in serious harm or death to the patient. Brooks was a first-year law student that year, which is a small detail, but it marks how young the concept is.
Here's the distinction that matters. Not every iatrogenic death is a Never Event. They're a narrow subset, the most egregious failures, and they signal a complete breakdown in the system rather than one bad outcome. They're also the cases that tend to become valid malpractice claims. If you work in patient safety, that's the category to watch.
A country that looked like a Never Event
By late spring 2020, the picture was grim. ICUs across the country were at capacity. Morgues were filling up. Masks and other protective equipment were scarce, and health officials were scrambling to understand how fast COVID-19 spread and how far it reached.
Brooks took that scene and turned it into a frame: What was the United States if not a Never Event itself, a failing system full of preventable errors that left serious harm and death in its wake? The idea stuck with her. It's a powerful metaphor, and it does real work. It's also a little too tidy. Systems don't fail in neat categories, and the metaphor can make a national crisis sound like a single defect with a single fix.
Balancing the impossible
Brooks was not sitting in a hospital that morning. She was in bed, laptop on her knees, trying to run her department while managing three children aged two, four, and six. Her four-year-old, Sinclair, was standing behind her, doing her hair. Her two-year-old, Yves, was perched on Brooks's ankles, holding out for a diaper and pleading in a whisper, because whispering was the compromise the household had reached after too many meetings got interrupted.
The domestic picture was just as strained. Yves had started refusing to use the potty, insisting on a diaper and only going if her mother watched her squat behind the rocking chair where she'd once been nursed and sung to. Brooks read the regression as a reaction to the lockdown's broken routines. She admits she didn't see it that way at the time. She was mentally and emotionally absent, even when her daughter reached out for her.
Her husband, a journalist, was also working, often taking source calls on walks around the neighborhood. Brooks was angry that he wasn't stepping in during her calls, and she felt entitled to more leeway because she was serving people on the front line. He wasn't. Brooks later concluded that her frustration, however understandable, had been misdirected. The household was running on fumes. Between the two of them, they managed to shower every four or five days during the first seven months of lockdown.
The math of the house was brutal, too. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner for five people, every day, came to 105 servings a week. If Brooks didn't produce them, nobody would eat. That was the kind of invisible labor pandemic parenting had quietly assigned to working mothers across the country, including the ones with a willing partner in the next room.
Brooks's own job was hard enough. As the hospital's director of enterprise health care risk management and insurance, she handled operational, financial, strategic, and legal matters, along with medical malpractice, cyber, and excess coverage. The days were unpredictable. A patient might threaten a receptionist of two decades. A fertility clinic might need advice on a dispute between divorced former patients who each claimed the same embryos. Brooks once had to deal with a surgeon who insisted he met care standards when the record said otherwise. She even fielded a request about insuring surgeons who had been asked to operate on a gorilla from the local zoo.
Still, she described her work as clean-up duty. Dr Gordon, by contrast, was the one walking into the emergency. And yet that gap is also where Brooks's sense of the impossible came from. "I thought I was such a clever clogs," she writes, "I was balancing the impossible." By the end of the year, she'd see that she hadn't balanced anything. She'd been the worst version of herself with her kids, had her biggest fight with her husband, and had worn down the people she loved most. "It's nearly impossible to multitask empathy," she concludes, and pandemic parenting was largely about splintering yourself and not noticing that the splintering was leaving you in pieces.
The call about John Doe
Dr Gordon's account got worse. The patient was a John Doe who arrived by ambulance with no identification and only an incomplete witness report. He had either jumped or fallen from a 16-foot overpass onto concrete. Brooks winced. She wanted to know which it was, and she kept returning to that question for weeks. Did the man do this to himself, or did something happen to him? More immediately, she wondered whether the team's efforts had caused him further harm, and whether he had been alone in the building. No next of kin had been notified. Nobody was there to tell him his life would likely change forever.
Dr Gordon blamed himself. He was the trauma lead, he said, and "this one is entirely on me." Brooks pushed back, and she did it with the experience of someone who had spent years on root-cause analysis. Never Events rarely come down to one person, she told him. They usually grow out of a chain of small errors and oversights that line up into catastrophe. "They're system failures," she said, and she expected the review would show the same pattern here.
It's the same argument she'd make at dinner parties before the pandemic, when people griped about the country's direction. "When things go really wrong, rarely does it come down to one person," she'd say. "Broken people don't break the system; it's almost always the other way around." It's a conviction she applies to hospitals and households alike, and one she'd come to test on her own family within a year, when she made the decision to move them to unfamiliar soil an ocean away.
A Broken System, Seen From the Kitchen Table
That night, after the kids were asleep, Jamie Brooks kept turning over a line she'd left for Dr Gordon on the day of his Never Event: broken people don't break the system; broken systems break people. It's a deliberate inversion, and it's the spine of the whole account. The blame lands on the structure, not on the individuals who are just trying to hold it together. Never Events, a term the [Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality](https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/never-events) uses for serious, preventable medical errors, are a clear case. They're failures of the system that happen to individuals.
The pandemic didn't create the fault lines. It exposed them. Health care, child care, education, and the basic protection of citizens had been cracking for years, and COVID-19 pushed all of it into view at once. Legal scholars Michael Saks and Stephan Landsman have written about the scale of healthcare harm and the legal tools meant to address it, and Brooks's point lands the same way: the damage isn't random. It's structural.
Here's the uncomfortable part. Brooks saw how those pressures stacked up and pushed her away from what she held most true: she was there to protect the children she had brought into the world. Protecting them meant more than shielding them from COVID-19. It meant shielding them from her own overstretched, frayed parenting choices. She was physically home while everything stopped, but she was absent in the ways that counted. Their young minds couldn't make sense of that stillness, and she knew it.
With Dr Gordon and John Doe still on her mind, she told her husband as they got ready for bed that she'd had enough. "There is no safe or viable life for us here in the United States. It's an entirely broken system. Our best and only option would be to leave. We've got to leave." He looked at her, and she could see he understood. This wasn't a drill.
It's a personal decision, not a policy argument, and that's what makes it telling. When a parent with a family to protect starts planning an exit, the problems are no longer abstract. They're sitting at the kitchen table.