The real test of the USDA’s Thrifty Food Plan isn’t whether a shopper can hit its budget. It’s what they have to do to get there. Paul Greenberg, the James Beard Award-winning writer and self-described cheapskate, took on a week of food shopping in New York City with a 2026 allowance of $64.90. He mostly stayed under it by shopping across neighborhoods and store chains, growing some of his own greens, and making bread at home.
The Receipt follows readers’ weekly food spending, from groceries and restaurant meals to coffee and snacks. This special edition tracks Greenberg’s attempt to live on the USDA plan. The result is a useful test of the budget—and a reminder that the price of eating well depends heavily on where you shop and how much work you can do yourself.
Greenberg says he has always hunted for bargains, regardless of whether his books are selling or the stock market is falling. He’ll cross the street to save more than two dollars on a gallon of milk. That habit has become harder to dismiss as food prices climb: since January 2024, sirloin steak prices have risen 21% and romaine lettuce 27%. Coffee, by 2026, costs more than 50% more than it did the last time the Kansas City Chiefs won the Super Bowl.
What the USDA budget buys
The USDA created the Thrifty Food Plan in 1975 and revised it in 2021 to model a healthy diet across food groups. Its shopping budgets vary by age and gender. Greenberg adjusted the 2021 figures for 2026 inflation; as a man in his 50s, he had $64.90 for the week, based on the USDA’s September 2026 cost estimate.
He generally beat the plan’s category limits using his normal shopping routine, without resorting to the meal Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins recently described: “$3 a meal for a piece of chicken, a piece of broccoli, you know, a corn tortilla and one other thing.” The budget may be possible on paper. Whether it should require this much searching is another question.
Shopping around for protein and dairy
Greenberg’s approach starts with rejecting loyalty to a single supermarket. In Manhattan, he looks for “golden corners” where Trader Joe’s, Target, and Lidl sit near one another, making it easy to compare prices in one trip. His protein and dairy purchases came in below the USDA allowances:
| Proteins | Amount | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Chicken breasts | 1 lb | $2.20 at Target |
| Pork loin | 2 lb | $4.00 at Lidl |
| Ground turkey | 1 lb | $5.00 at Trader Joe’s |
| Eggs | 1 dozen (1.5 lb) | $2.00 at Lidl |
| Greenberg’s total | $13.20 | |
| USDA allowance | $17.67 |
| Dairy | Amount | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Whole milk | ½ gallon (4.3 lb) | $1.70 at Lidl |
| Whole milk yogurt | 1 quart (2 lb) | $4.00 at Target |
| Greenberg’s total | $5.70 | |
| USDA allowance | $8.66 |
Beef and cheese are absent. Greenberg avoids beef because of its high carbon emissions, and says ground turkey works well in Bolognese at three dollars less per pound. He also skips cheese over its climate impact, though he doesn’t know why the USDA plan leaves it off its list.
Produce from carts, gardens, and Chinatown
Greenberg buys whatever produce is cheapest and available, rather than prioritizing fruits and vegetables that keep for a long time. New York’s fruit carts are central to that strategy. Vendors buy wholesale and discount produce with a short shelf life; his regular Lower Manhattan vendor often has a one-dollar special, and their relationship helps him choose what’s still good. If berries are nearly overripe, he turns them into jam.
For salad greens, he grows his own in a community garden. His membership, seeds, and fertilizer cost about $50 a year, and tending the plot takes roughly an hour each week—about 50 cents per salad. He says the garden also avoids the risk of cyclosporiasis that concerns shoppers buying packaged greens; information on the parasite is available from Bon Appétit.
For other vegetables, he shops in Manhattan’s Chinatown, where vendors may have direct links to smaller farms and wholesalers that aren’t part of mainstream supermarket supply chains. The California Migration Museum counts roughly 50 Chinatowns across the United States, including in nearly every major city.
| Vegetables | Amount | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Cauliflower | 2 lb | $1.00 at a fruit cart |
| Bok choy | 2 lb | $2.00 in Chinatown |
| Salad | 2 harvested salads | $1.00 from the community garden |
| Potatoes | 2.5 lb | $1.50 at a fruit cart |
| Carrots | 2 lb | $1.50 at Lidl |
| Cucumbers | 2 lb | $1.00 at a fruit cart |
| Mixed peppers | 2 lb | $1.00 at a fruit cart |
| Greenberg’s total | $9.00 | |
| USDA allowance | $14.97 |
| Fruit | Amount | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Strawberries | 1 lb | $1.00 at a fruit cart |
| Melon | 2 lb | $2.00 at a fruit cart |
| Blackberries | 1 lb | $3.00 at a fruit cart |
| Apples | 3 lb | $2.00 at a fruit cart |
| Greenberg’s total | $8.00 | |
| USDA allowance | $8.19 |
Fruit was the closest call: even with bargain prices, Greenberg only just met the USDA limit. Nearly half of the plan’s fruit budget is allocated to juice, which he considers a poor stand-in for whole fruit.
Grains take planning—and a kitchen
The plan allows $3.76 for a week’s refined grains, including rice, pasta, bread, and tortillas. That budget is tight: a loaf of Wonder Bread at Walmart costs $2.47, while a pound of pasta could push the category over its limit. The $6.94 allowance for whole grains goes further, but a whole-wheat loaf priced at $2.97 would still use more than half of it.
Greenberg stayed within budget by buying rice and beans at Patel Brothers, a national Indian grocery chain, where those staples cost between 80 cents and two dollars per pound. He also bakes bread: Target’s house-brand whole-wheat flour costs $2.69 for five pounds, and about a pound and a quarter makes a loaf. That puts his sandwich bread at roughly 67 cents per week.
Where the savings come from
Dry goods are the least dramatic part of the haul, but the arithmetic is hard to ignore: rice from Patel Brothers cost $1.50 for 1.5 pounds, a homemade two-pound whole-wheat loaf came to 67 cents, and Trader Joe’s pasta was $1 a pound. Together, the grains cost $3.17 against an $11.05 TFP allowance.
The same pattern holds for pantry odds and ends. Forgetting salt, sugar, oil, or coffee can turn a small shopping trip into an expensive one, so it pays to remember which nearby shops offer the best prices. Making jam from fruit-cart produce and mayonnaise at home can also cut costs; the estimate here is 50 cents for half a pound of jam and 25 cents for half a pound of mayonnaise. Vegetable oil from Target cost 71 cents, while a quarter-pound of Lavazza coffee from Amazon cost $1.50. The four items came to $2.96, below the $4.36 allowance.
The totals—and their limits
Across all six categories, the shopping trip produced 37.48 pounds of food for $42.03. The USDA plan listed 40.24 pounds at $64.90. The comparison looks persuasive: the actual haul cost $22.87 less, even though it weighed 2.76 pounds less. Yet the category totals complicate any simple victory lap. Dairy came to 6.3 pounds versus 11.76 planned, while the fruit totals were nearly even at 7.0 and 7.1 pounds.
And the method matters. This shopper had grown children, freelance hours, and access to a large city’s scattered bargains. That kind of search takes time and mobility. A working parent in a food desert, without spare hours for bargain hunting or a community garden, faces a very different calculation. These numbers show what one person could manage under particular circumstances; they don’t prove that the same budget works for everyone.
The USDA allowance deserves a harder look, especially when food costs keep rising and families also depend on programs such as food stamps and healthcare. A country among the world’s wealthiest can set a more adequate standard than asking people to shop like full-time price detectives.