Reviews and audience reaction
Taika Waititi’s response to Klara and the Sun’s weak reviews has put the film’s divide between critics and audiences in focus. The Jenna Ortega-led adaptation has a 24% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, compared with a 74% audience score, and has earned less than $2 million at the box office against a reported $20 million budget. Those figures point in different directions: viewers who’ve rated the film are substantially more positive than critics, while ticket sales so far remain modest relative to its reported cost.
The scores measure different things. A critics’ score reflects the share of reviews counted as positive, while an audience score reflects submitted viewer ratings; neither tells you how many people saw the film or why they liked or disliked it. That distinction matters here. The audience figure suggests a more favorable response among participating viewers, but it doesn’t establish that the film has found a large audience.
Waititi, the director of Thor: Ragnarok and Jojo Rabbit, addressed the reviews in an Instagram post. He shared a screenshot of a Screen Rant article about the audience score and wrote:
“I haven't read a review of anything aimed at me or my peers in almost 15 years. But I do listen to the people. So, this Halloween, let's spare a thought for those sad lost souls who couldn't achieve their dreams of becoming artists, and thus settled, and became critics. The same people who also hated 'Jojo Rabbit.' Irrelevant. Out of touch. Obsolete. In the bin.”
His post makes the audience score the central counterpoint to the critics’ verdict. It also turns a difference in opinion into a broader attack on reviewers as a group. That’s a sharper move than simply arguing that critics misread this particular film, and it risks keeping attention on the dispute rather than on what viewers found in the adaptation.
A stark split in reception
The film adapts Kazuo Ishiguro’s 2021 novel. Ortega plays Klara, an Artificial Friend who meets Josie, played by Mia Tharia, and becomes a source of hope for Josie’s family through her loyalty and curiosity. The premise gives the story a clear emotional center: Klara’s perspective and devotion shape how the family’s troubles are seen. Many critics have argued that the movie falls short of the novel’s potential.
That criticism points to a familiar challenge for adaptations. A novel can build meaning through interior thought, measured pacing, and details that don’t need to be explained aloud; a film has to make those choices visible and audible. A version that preserves the story’s central ideas can still feel thinner to readers if it doesn’t give those ideas the same weight on screen. The existing reviews suggest that, for many critics, the adaptation hasn’t fully bridged that gap.
Audience ratings offer a different signal, but they don’t resolve the question of whether the film succeeds as an adaptation. Viewers may respond to the performances, the emotional premise, or the film on its own terms. A rating can register approval without explaining what worked, and the gap between the two scores leaves that explanation open.
Waititi’s comparison to Jojo Rabbit doesn’t match that film’s reception. The 2019 comedy-drama was generally well reviewed, earned a Best Picture nomination and won the 2020 Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay. It also brought in $90 million worldwide against a $14 million budget. The comparison may express Waititi’s frustration with critics, but the two films’ critical records and commercial outcomes differ.
Klara and the Sun features Ortega, known for Wednesday, alongside Oscar nominee Amy Adams. Those names give the film recognizable leads, but star power doesn’t automatically produce broad interest. The film’s modest reported budget still leaves a wide gap between its $20 million cost and current ticket sales. The numbers here are underwhelming, even if the reported budget gives the film a different scale from a large studio release.
Waititi’s recent box-office record
The response lands amid a more uneven run for the filmmaker. Thor: Ragnarok became a major hit and gave the Marvel franchise a fresh boost. Its follow-up, Thor: Love and Thunder, also succeeded commercially, though its reception was cooler. Waititi’s 2023 sports comedy Next Goal Wins underperformed at the box office. Taken together, those outcomes make it harder to describe his recent work with one simple label: he’s had commercial success, along with a film that struggled to find an audience.
That history may help explain why the current argument has drawn attention. A director with both major hits and weaker results can’t treat one response as a complete verdict on a career, and a single audience score can’t settle the case for a film. Here’s the thing: criticism can be unfair or unpersuasive, but dismissing critics wholesale doesn’t explain why some viewers and reviewers reached such different conclusions about this story.
Other directors have publicly attacked critics, including Gods of Egypt filmmaker Alex Proyas and Clerks director Kevin Smith. Smith later reconciled with reviewers, but such disputes tend to draw attention back to a director’s work and its reception. That attention can keep a title in conversation. It doesn’t, by itself, change the film’s reviews or bring people into theaters.
What the split means for the film
Reviews can shape a film’s reputation, but they rarely determine ticket sales on their own. The gap between Klara and the Sun’s audience and critics scores makes the split visible; its box-office performance suggests that favorable viewer ratings haven’t yet translated into broad demand. The film is currently in theaters.
If you’re working in this space, the distinction between a positive rating and a broad audience is the point to watch. A score describes the people who submitted ratings; ticket sales show whether enough moviegoers chose to see the film during its current theatrical run. Those measures can move in different directions, particularly when a film’s appeal is concentrated among viewers who’ve already sought it out.
And yet. A weak opening tally doesn’t tell us how every viewer felt, just as a strong audience score doesn’t establish that the film has reached a large public. The available figures offer a snapshot, not a complete account of its eventual performance. For now, the adaptation’s clearest story is the gap between a warmer response from audience raters and a modest box-office showing.