Marvel’s next Avengers film has already brought in nearly as much from advance ticket sales as Supergirl earned during its entire theatrical run. Avengers: Doomsday had collected $125 million in presales by the end of October, according to a Forbes report. That figure puts the film within reach of Supergirl’s $126.5 million worldwide gross—and it still won’t open until December 18, 2026.
The comparison says more about the gap between two very different releases than it does about their eventual box office standings. Doomsday is an Avengers event built around characters with decades of audience recognition. Supergirl, despite Milly Alcock’s well-received performance, was a harder sell: its $126.5 million gross fell short of its reported $170 million to $186 million budget.
DC Studios has had brighter results elsewhere. James Gunn and Peter Safran’s developing universe has delivered the crowd-pleasing Superman and the HBO series Lanterns, showing room for both lighter superhero stories and darker crime drama. Supergirl’s commercial performance stands out against that early progress. The film itself drew praise in /Film’s review, which singled out Alcock as the self-destructive Kryptonian hero.
What the presales figure can—and can’t—tell us
Doomsday crossed $50 million in presales in September, 100 days before its scheduled release, setting a Marvel record at that point. The climb to $125 million signals strong early demand, but advance sales tend to reflect the most committed fans. They don’t guarantee that wider audiences will keep buying tickets once the film opens.
That distinction matters. The Fantastic Four: First Steps also drew early support from franchise loyalists, then saw its box office falter. Forbes raised that history as a reason not to treat Doomsday’s presales as a sure forecast. Still, this Avengers film has a combination of recognizable names that gives it a stronger event profile: Robert Downey Jr. returns to the MCU as Victor Von Doom, alongside familiar Marvel characters and members of the 20th Century Fox-era X-Men.
That cast gives Marvel a clear route to broad interest, much as Deadpool & Wolverine did in 2024. Yet the presales milestone measures urgency among early buyers, not the film’s final reach. Doomsday’s eventual performance will show whether that initial enthusiasm extends beyond established fans.
Supergirl’s box office raises a separate question for DC
Supergirl’s result also puts pressure on DC’s choices for the next phase of its franchise. The strategy that once turned lesser-known heroes into major draws has become less dependable as audiences tire of sprawling shared universes and stories spread across films and streaming shows. Marvel’s own output has faced that fatigue, making the scale of Doomsday’s early demand notable—but not conclusive.
Gunn’s choice to follow Superman with a Supergirl film centered on a less familiar version of the character carried a commercial risk. Alcock had appeared briefly in Superman, and Jason Momoa’s Lobo offered another recognizable element, but the film still had to establish its lead as a theatrical draw. Its earnings suggest that the setup didn’t translate into broad turnout. DC will need its upcoming releases to show that the miss was specific to this film.
For Marvel, the challenge is converting a fan-heavy presales base into sustained attendance. The film’s early teasers drew a mixed response, and Downey’s casting as Doctor Doom left some viewers questioning the choice. The growing advance sales suggest the campaign has built momentum since then. They’re a strong opening signal, but the theatrical run will determine whether Doomsday can carry that excitement to a much wider audience.