“We Both Needed A Friend”: Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Got Married Six Weeks Ago. Now Their Ex-Spouses Have Married Each Other, Too
All’s well that ends well?
The story has taken a turn that sounds almost too neat: Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes married each other, and six weeks later their former spouses, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, did the same. The four people caught up in morning television’s 2022 relationship scandal are now two married couples. That symmetry is striking, though it doesn’t tell us what any of them think of it.
Shue and Fiebig’s wedding
Shue, the 59-year-old actor known for Melrose Place, and Fiebig, a 48-year-old immigration attorney, married on Sunday, Nov. 1, at their 92-acre country estate near Stockton, New Jersey. The ceremony came just 11 days after news broke that they were engaged, according to People. The Daily Mail first reported the wedding and published photos showing Fiebig in an off-the-shoulder lace gown with a matching shawl.


That wedding followed Robach and Holmes’s own marriage by about six weeks. The former Good Morning America co-hosts married in secret, bringing the same four names from the 2022 scandal into an unexpected new arrangement. If you’re trying to make sense of the timeline, the key detail is that Robach married Shue in 2010, while Holmes married Fiebig that same year. Here’s how the story began: a look back at the timeline.



Posted Nov. 2, 2026 UTC. Reporting by Mariam Sharia, BuzzFeed Contributor.
Workplace chemistry became public scrutiny
Robach and Shue had built a blended family from earlier marriages: her two daughters and his three sons. Holmes and Fiebig, meanwhile, had a daughter, Sabine, in 2013. The family details matter because the story soon pulled four people—and their children—into a public dispute over timing.
Robach and Holmes had worked together at ABC News since 2014. Their relationship became more visible after they began co-hosting GMA3: What You Need to Know in September 2020. Viewers could see the easy rapport on air; the two also spent time together away from the studio, training for the 2022 NYC Half Marathon and running the NYC Marathon the next year. This is more significant than it might seem: their public closeness gave later reports a ready-made timeline to scrutinize.
Good Morning America / YouTube / Via youtube.com
Good Morning America / YouTube / Via youtube.com
Good Morning America / YouTube / Via youtube.com
There was a social connection, too. In December 2016, Fiebig posted a selfie with Shue and said she “loved hanging out with our GMA family,” especially Robach and her husband. Robach replied with a heart emoji. The following year, all four appeared in a photo at Shue’s birthday party with ABC colleagues including Michael Strahan and Sara Haines.
@marileefiebig / Instagram / Via Instagram: @marileefiebigThe timeline became the story
On Nov. 30, 2022, the Daily Mail published photos of Robach and Holmes looking cozy and holding hands. Both were still legally married, and neither had announced a separation. The images triggered intense coverage and allegations of an affair, but they couldn’t establish when a relationship began. That uncertainty drove competing accounts. The timeline became a major source of speculation: Page Six suggested the relationship developed during half-marathon training in March 2022, while the Daily Mail speculated it began in June, when they were in London covering Queen Elizabeth II’s Platinum Jubilee.
@MarissaSaysWhat / X.com / Via x.com
Robach later said the relationship began in August, after both had separated from their spouses. On the Dec. 5, 2023 debut of the Amy and T.J. Podcast, she said: “Everyone in my tight circle knew I was getting divorced.” She added, “I took my ring off [in] early August. It was very clear to anyone who knew me that I was in the middle of a divorce.” Her account appeared in NBC News’ report.
@ajrobach / Instagram / Via instagram.com
ABC took Robach and Holmes off the air temporarily within days of the photos’ publication; they were eventually removed from their roles. Their marriages were also ending. Holmes filed for divorce from Fiebig in December 2022, while Robach and Shue’s separation was already underway; their divorce was finalized in March 2023.They still reject the cheating narrative
Robach and Holmes have acknowledged that they could have handled their relationship differently. But they say the public story got a key point wrong: they were exposed as a couple, they argue, not caught cheating on their spouses.

A striking coincidence around the exes
The timeline adds an unexpected coda. On Dec. 5, 2023—one year after ABC fired Robach and Holmes, and the day they launched Amy and T.J.—news broke that their former spouses, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, were dating. Page Six reported the news that day.

