November’s Bake Club Takes On Thanksgiving Pie in Three Ways
Three pies, three approaches to the holiday centerpiece. Bon Appétit’s November Bake Club pairs a lesson in flaky pastry with a cranberry meringue showpiece and a bourbon caramel apple pie, then makes room for anyone who’d rather skip rolling dough. The recipes are by Test Kitchen editors Jesse Szewczyk and Shilpa Uskokovic, who promise to make Thanksgiving dessert feel manageable.
Jesse and Shilpa are the resident bakers behind the club, a monthly invitation to make a tested recipe, share photos and questions, and talk through the successes and failures. Think baking book club, with more butter. The aim is to build confidence in the process, not just deliver a finished dessert.
How to bake along
Save the monthly recipe and bake it. Then join the Bon Appétit Bake Club chat on Substack for a look at how recipes are developed, or post your photos on Instagram with #BABakeClub.
Got questions or feedback? Leave a note on the recipe page in the Epicurious app. You can also email the editors at [email protected]; selected questions may appear on the podcast. Each recipe’s episode arrives the following month in the Bon Appétit podcast feed.
November 2026: Thanksgiving pies
The month’s lineup makes a useful point: a Thanksgiving pie doesn’t have to mean one particular level of effort. For two recipes, the editors are bringing back their flaky, croissant-like pie crust, first published in 2022 and now the dough the Test Kitchen uses for its pies. That’s a strong endorsement from professional cooks, though the article doesn’t explain what makes this particular dough their lasting choice.
The single-crust Cranberry Meringue Pie is a chance to practice blind baking, with tall slices designed to make an impression. The Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie takes the more involved route: a lattice top, a double crust, and fruit coated in bourbon caramel.
And if making pastry from scratch is where your holiday plans stall, there’s the Salted Coffee Custard Pie. Its oatmeal crust is pressed into the pan, then filled with smooth coffee custard and topped with mascarpone whipped cream. Three distinct pies; one less reason to assume Thanksgiving dessert has to be a marathon.
October 2026: Salt Bread
Salt bread borrows its appeal from several traditions: it’s known as shio pan in Japan and sogeum-ppang in Korea, and combines a soft bun with croissant-like layers. A piece of salted butter tucked inside melts as it bakes, leaving the bottom crisp and savory. Deputy food editor Hana Asbrink’s preferred approach is hands-on: split one open, enjoy the buttery hollow, then peel apart the layers.
September 2026: Apple Pie Fritters
Apple pie fritters aim for the farm-stand feeling of warm cinnamon-sugar doughnuts after a day of apple picking. The apple-studded dough brings the fruit, sugar, spice, and fried richness, without requiring yeast or the wait for dough to rise.
August 2026: Plum Cheesecake Karpatka
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Micah Marie Morton, Prop Styling by Adrian Ababović
Karpatka gets its dramatic shape from two airy rounds of pâte à choux, traditionally sandwiching pastry cream softened with whipped cream or made into crème mousseline. This version makes a bigger departure than the name suggests: a no-bake cheesecake filling streaked with homemade plum jam. The make-ahead format is handy, and the fruit keeps summer on the table a little longer.
Make the RecipeJuly 2026: Sweet Corn-Coconut Crunch Butter Mochi
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Thu Buser, Prop Styling by Alexandra Massillon
This midsummer Bake Club cake is vivid yellow and pleasantly springy. Corn, fresh or frozen, gets blended with sweetened condensed milk; sweet rice flour gives the batter its structure. The result earns its appeal through texture as much as flavor: it yields with a slight chew, bringing together buttered corn, toasted coconut, and nutty caramel.
Sweet rice flourMake the RecipeJune 2026: Tiny Tomato Galettes
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Micah Marie Morton, Prop Styling by Alexandra Massillon
These little galettes have the easy appeal of a tomato sandwich with the crisp edges of pastry. Black pepper seasons the pie dough, which bakes into flaky layers without special equipment. A garlicky mayonnaise with Parmesan and herbs sits under each tomato slice, separating the fruit’s juices from the folded crust. That small layer does useful work: it helps keep the pastry delicate instead of soggy. —Rebecca Firkser, Test Kitchen editorMake the RecipeMay 2026: Whole Lemon Bars
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Kaitlin Wayne, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness
Using only lemon juice and zest leaves much of the fruit’s flavor behind. These bars put two whole lemons into the curd, then strain out the pulp, keeping the pith’s bitterness and the peel’s aromatic oils alongside the juice’s acidity. The result has the sharp, sweet punch of Lemonhead candy. It’s a bold take on a familiar bar, with the lemon turned way up.
Get the RecipeApril 2026: Strawberry Shortcake Roll
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Micah Morton, Prop Styling by Christina Allen
This roll cake started as a birthday dessert for deputy food editor Hana Asbrink last year, made with whipped cream and small, jewel-red strawberries. It was such a hit that it joined Bon Appétit Bake Club. The combination is straightforward and well judged: fluffy cake, vanilla-speckled cream, and juicy berries, a natural fit for spring alongside tender asparagus. Roll cakes can be fussy to shape, but an oil-based chiffon sponge makes this one easier to roll without cracks.
Get the RecipeMarch 2026: Chocolate Guinness Cake
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Kaitlin Wayne, Prop Styling by Sean Dooley
After the previous month’s cheddar biscuits, Bake Club turns back to dessert with a chocolate loaf built around Guinness stout. The stout brings a malty, full-bodied note, while the unusually tender crumb comes from reverse creaming: rub butter into the dry ingredients by hand until it nearly vanishes. That limits gluten development, and it means you can make the cake without a stand mixer.
Get the RecipeFebruary 2026: Cheddar Biscuits With Old Bay
Elliott Jerome Brown Jr.Cheddar Biscuits With Old Bay
A hot, flaky biscuit delivers much of homemade bread’s pleasure with far less time and work. This month’s version folds in plenty of cheese and Old Bay, and a quick lamination gives the biscuits tall, distinct layers. The method borrows from croissant-making, but you don’t need special equipment. A [bench scraper](https://www.amazon.com/Ateco-Bench-Scraper-Wood-Handle/dp/B000KEYDHW/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1KVJK2U25NS5M&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.Bw1EsDUQuHngyJToi6GzOWonf2K8UxIQsOMmyKVImTqm7Zdb5NWgKuMmH12iGZZEjyRIYulpiX7-515zsk2LpFzpYKLkXNGgRHuvLISK0PtRBkkq81iCz9Si-dQ1SM1qJAh9XVr9K-nwX8r_BqazxuzVFbGaMG9D2byAZx7MpO-l9K9ydXEkjJ9jHbGikdJ7IGyHawXACLlboOsRx9tqvgKap9EZm2Bhpx91miQUki_lXLEbCWDbDR4CcAYl_R47Rx6fSNZhSufwKJ0lA5Zm1P_J-Db7EYmBGUZJ_Cg5xh4.T-jlaGQip1xgQOLT-C0VydWpSUY8yqtrPZDkm-RJOaA&dib_tag=se&keywords=ateco%2Bbench%2Bscraper&qid=1769471858&s=home-garden&sprefix=ateco%2Bbench%2Bscraper%2Cgarden%2C116&sr=1-1&th=1">makes shaping the dough easier. Chris, who writes [From the Test Kitchen](https://fromthetestkitchen.substack.com/), recently gave me a set from [Gestura](https://gesturautensils.com/products/flexi-dough-scraper); its compact size, sturdy build, curved edges, and minimal handle have made it a favorite. For the lamination method, see [this guide](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/how-to-fold-for-laminated-biscuits). If you’re in the mood for another bread project, try [homemade cheddar-jalapeño bread](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/no-knead-cheddar-jalapeno-bread). Make the cheddar biscuits with Old BayJanuary 2026: Homemade Bagels

Boiling before baking is what gives these bagels their chewy bite, bronzed surface, and dense but tender center. The recipe makes a dozen from pantry staples, though it still asks for a little time. Top them with sesame seeds, Parmesan, furikake, or flaky salt—or use whatever you have on hand. Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Jesse Szewczyk, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran.
Make the homemade bagelsDecember 2025: Cherry and Chocolate Pavlova

This pavlova takes its cues from Black Forest cake: chocolate, cream, cherries, and kirsch, the cherry brandy. That dessert has traveled well beyond Bavaria; in Chennai, India, where I grew up, one bakery sold tall triangular slices that my parents brought home when I did well on school tests. Pavlova can crack, weep, or turn soggy, so the sugar-to-white ratio matters: use two parts sugar by weight for every part egg whites. The result should be crisp, white, and sturdy. Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Shilpa Uskokovic and Jesse Szewczyk, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran.
Make the cherry and chocolate pavlovaNovember 2025: Giant, Gooey Cinnamon Roll

This oversized roll puts the sticky center front and center, and it’s been a crowd-pleaser nearly every time I’ve baked it. Instant vanilla pudding stirred into cinnamon sugar helps recreate the gooey filling associated with mall cinnamon rolls; the mix’s modified food starch does the work. It’s big enough to slice like a cake. You may still end up pulling it apart by hand. Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Shilpa Uskokovic, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran.
Make the giant cinnamon roll