Ethan Klein’s reported six-month affair has set off a dispute that reaches beyond his marriage: his brother-in-law Moses Hacmon and Hacmon’s wife, Trisha Paytas, are now being pulled into the fallout. The family connection matters here. Paytas once worked closely with Klein, and fans are revisiting their old disagreements for signs she anticipated what would happen.
Hila Klein disclosed the affair on Instagram, saying she had been “living in a nightmare” after learning it had continued for six months. Her post made her the first to address the news publicly.
The H3 Podcast, named for the couple’s combined initials and co-hosted by both, quickly distanced itself from Ethan. “We stand with Hila and will support her every step of the way. We’re disgusted by Ethan’s actions and the hurt he has caused. We all deserved better: Hila, us, and you,” the team said on Instagram. Ethan, for his part, said in an Instagram story that he was “working with Hila to urgently remove my ownership and financial stakes” in the show; that statement was reported here.
Old criticism returns
The public reaction picked up speed when former Try Guy Ned Fulmer, himself known for an affair, criticized Klein on X. The irony is hard to miss: Klein had previously condemned Fulmer on his podcast for betraying his family and turning the affair into a public scandal. Fulmer’s criticism has made those past remarks newly relevant.
Paytas’s past with Klein adds another layer. The two co-hosted Frenemies, and fans are circulating old clips they say show Paytas predicted trouble. Some have even revived the idea that she might be psychic, a claim explored in earlier coverage. The clips may show sharp instincts—or simply someone who knew Klein well enough to recognize when he wasn’t being truthful. Either way, the evidence doesn’t establish that she foresaw this particular scandal.
The family connection makes every claim more complicated
For context, Moses Hacmon is Hila Klein’s brother. That makes the estrangement at the center of this story a family split, not just a feud between online personalities.
Trisha Paytas and Moses addressed the conflict on Episode 323 of the Just Trish podcast on YouTube, published Oct. 27. They discussed Ethan and Hila Klein and what they described as false claims the couple had made about them since the relationship broke down.
They said they’ve had no contact with Hila, Ethan, or their immediate family for more than five years. That distance also means they haven’t spoken with the Kleins about the recent cheating allegations. The podcast comments are their account of the dispute, not a conversation with the people at its center.
Paytas said she wasn’t joining people celebrating the allegations. “It’s hard to talk about,” she said, adding that she understood why people who felt wronged by Ethan might rejoice, but couldn’t share that reaction because “it’s Moses’s family.” She also pointed to the children in both families: they’re the same age, she said, and the situation calls for sensitivity.
Hacmon then challenged specific stories he said his brother-in-law had told about him, including that he trained as a pilot, served in combat, and killed people. Hacmon called those claims fabricated and said they could be checked against public records. “I never graduated from flight school. I never was a pilot. I’ve never been in combat. I never hurt anyone. I never shot a gun on anyone,” he said.
Paytas also admitted to feeling relief when Ethan announced his podcast was ending, then said she felt ashamed of that reaction given how painfully the situation had concluded. She may revisit the end of Frenemies in her upcoming memoir, scheduled for Nov. 10, 2026; the fragment describes that discussion as rumored, so it’s not confirmed.
Her closing summary was blunt: “We tried everything. And not only was it met with zero grace and zero compassion, but just more retaliation.”
Freedom from the next family blowup
After more than five years of a very public rift with Moses Hacmon’s sister and brother-in-law, Trisha Paytas says the break has brought a sense of relief. The significance is less about a single family dispute than the strain of living with the expectation that another one could erupt. Paytas described that uncertainty as a constant worry about what might happen next.