The dispute is about more than one castmate’s wording
Tovah Feldshuh has pushed back against public figures who call Israel’s military campaign in Gaza a “genocide,” adding a pointed new note to the debate around her Nobody Wants This co-star Adam Brody. Brody drew criticism after calling for a “free Palestine” in a recent GQ interview. Feldshuh didn’t name him, so calling her comments a direct response to Brody would go further than the available evidence. Still, the connection is hard to miss.
Feldshuh’s criticism was explicit
“To accuse the Jewish people of genocide is wild,” Feldshuh said. “It’s right out of Hitler’s playbook. You take the victim and you make the victim the perpetrator.” That’s a forceful charge, and it frames the use of the term as an inversion of history. The interview excerpt, however, doesn’t establish whom she had in mind or whether she was responding specifically to Brody.
Feldshuh’s response: keep the work separate
The disagreement around Israel and Gaza is playing out alongside the launch of Nobody Wants This’s third season. The Netflix series follows the relationship between Noah, a rabbi played by Adam Brody, and Joanne, an agnostic podcaster played by Kristen Bell. Tovah Feldshuh plays Noah’s mother, Bina Roklov.
Feldshuh has said she believes Israel’s continued existence matters to the democratic and free world. Asked about any political tension on set, she described a practical approach: “My job, as Bina but also as Tovah, is to love the people on set at my place of work, to be kind.” When views differ, she said, she switches channels and does her job. That’s a clear boundary between personal conviction and workplace conduct, though it doesn’t resolve the underlying disagreement.
Brody, who was raised Jewish, told GQ last month that he considers the war a genocide and wants a free Palestine. He called the death and misery awful, said the situation felt overdue for a breaking point, and expressed hope that another administration could change policies contributing to it.
Those remarks drew criticism from Rabbi Steve Leder, a technical adviser on the show’s first season in 2024. In a video posted to Instagram on Sept. 29, Leder objected to what he saw as Brody’s flippant use of the word “genocide,” comparing the phrasing to casually requesting a table for two at Craig’s.
Erin Foster, the show’s creator, has also made clear that she and Brody don’t see the conflict the same way. In a teaser for an episode of the Not Skinny but Not Fat podcast, she said, “While I love Adam, I also disagree with him. And that’s okay.” Foster converted to Judaism before marrying music executive Simon Tikhman in 2019; she has said the series draws on their relationship.
That distinction matters for a show built around religion, romance, and family: disagreement among the people making it doesn’t automatically define the work or prevent them from working together. Feldshuh’s answer is less a political statement than a professional one. Whether viewers find that separation persuasive is another question.
Feldshuh’s recent credits include The Walking Dead and the 2023 Broadway revival of Funny Girl, which starred Lea Michele.
Watch a clip from Tovah Feldshuh’s UNscripted appearance on YouTube.
This article originally appeared on HuffPost.