Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes: Pumpkin, Pecan, Apple and More
2026-11-07 14:00
793 views
Explore Thanksgiving pie recipes from classic pumpkin, pecan and apple to cranberry meringue, butterscotch and chilled chocolate.
Thanksgiving pie, with room for the classics and the unexpected
Some of us are happy to finish Thanksgiving with cheesecake. The rest are already watching the pie table, ideally with whipped cream within reach. That’s the real promise of this collection: familiar holiday favorites, plus a few pies that make the usual lineup feel less predictable.
Start with the standards: silky pumpkin, gooey pecan, and apple under either a double crust or cinnamon crumble. Then take a turn toward cranberry meringue with lime-brightened curd, butterscotch custard capped with toasted marshmallow, or a pecan cream pie that piles on the layers. Chilled chocolate pies and citrus custards round things out. Some may even make a persuasive case for pie at breakfast the next morning.
Three pies to start with
BA’s Best Pumpkin Pie aims for balance: smooth custard, flaky butter crust, warming spice, and added depth from maple syrup and vanilla. It’s a Thanksgiving classic that has won over some pumpkin-pie skeptics. [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/best-pumpkin-pie), and see the [classic Thanksgiving menu](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/classic-thanksgiving-menu) for more holiday ideas.
Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie puts Honeycrisp apples beneath a lattice crust, with smoky burnt-sugar caramel and bourbon in the filling. Give it time to cool before slicing; impatience won’t help the presentation. [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/bourbon-caramel-apple-pie). The dish shown is the [East Fork Spun Iron Pie Dish](https://eastfork.com/products/iron-pie-plate?variant=42087465582671).
BA’s Best Pecan Pie comes with a strong endorsement from a reader in Chattanooga, Tennessee, who called it the best pecan pie recipe she’d ever used after many years of baking. That’s praise worth taking seriously. [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/bas-best-pecan-pie).
Need more ideas? Browse Bon Appétit’s [favorite pie recipes](https://www.bonappetit.com/gallery/pie-recipes) and [Thanksgiving desserts](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipes/slideshow/thanksgiving-desserts-slideshow). For help with pastry, consult the [guide to making better pie](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/guide-to-your-best-pie-yet) or its picks for the [best store-bought pie crusts](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/best-prepared-pie-crusts).
Pies for a sharper finish
The Cranberry Meringue Pie makes its case through contrast: tart cranberry-lime curd under a generous, sweet meringue topping. Give it a day to set before serving. Travis Rainey photographed the pie; Maggie Ruggiero handled food styling, and Adrian Ababović styled the props. The dish is an East Fork Spun Iron Pie Dish, provided by [East Fork](https://eastfork.com/products/iron-pie-plate?variant=42087465582671). [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/cranberry-meringue-pie).
Two ways to go deep
Claire Saffitz’s BA’s Best Apple Pie gets its depth from reduced cider, vanilla, and cardamom. Pink Ladies are the recommended filling, though [other baking apples](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/best-apples-for-baking-and-pie) can work too. The overhead shot of its golden-brown double crust is by Michael Graydon and Nikole Herriot. [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/best-apple-pie).
Pecan Cream Pie takes a more layered route: chopped pecans, brown-sugar custard, tangy whipped cream, then candied pecans on top. That’s a lot of texture and sweetness in one slice, so the contrast from the whipped cream has a real job to do. Travis Rainey took the photo, with food styling by Thu Buser and prop styling by Linden Elstran. [View the recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/pecan-cream-pie).
Two pies worth saving room for
The strongest finish here is a choice between spectacle and restraint. Detroit’s Sister Pie goes all in: flaky pastry holds dark chocolate ganache and salty-sweet butterscotch custard, capped with homemade marshmallow toasted into golden peaks. It’s a project, but the payoff sounds commensurate. Get the Toasted Marshmallow Butterscotch Pie recipe.
Toasted Marshmallow Butterscotch Pie — Jesse David Green
Then there’s pear pie, a quieter but persuasive case for adding another dessert to the Thanksgiving table. This classic Gourmet dessert pairs firm-ripe Anjou or Bartlett pears and a little nutmeg with a flaky lattice crust. Apples can stay; the point is that they don’t need to be the only pie on the table. Get the Pear Pie With Lattice Crust recipe.
Pear Pie With Lattice Crust — Photo by Joseph De Leo, Food Styling by Drew Aichele