This week’s strongest critical consensus spans sharply different territory: Walter Mosley’s crime fiction leads the fiction list, while nonfiction picks revisit Sherlock Holmes, death row, personal identity and Larry David’s career. The range is the story here. Reviewers are responding to books that pair distinctive voices with close attention to people and their contradictions.
Fiction: crime, culture and friendship
Walter Mosley’s Hanging & Burning, published by Little, Brown and Company, earns five rave reviews. It’s the fourth novel featuring King Oliver, and Booklist’s Donna Seaman points to Mosley’s command of character, dialogue and suspense, as well as the book’s attention to jazz, family and crime.
Sam Riviere’s Doppelgänger from Catapult draws two rave and two positive reviews. The novel takes aim at capital-C “Culture” and wider social habits. Writing in the Financial Times, Matthew Janney says Riviere avoids reproducing the behavior the book critiques, giving it a singular voice.
Pol Guasch’s Paradise Burns, from FSG Originals, receives two rave and one positive review. The novel’s central relationship between Líton and Rita gives the story its emotional anchor. Kirkus calls their friendship tender and steadfast, and praises the book as a perceptive portrait of friendship.
Lisa Kleypas’s Queen of Lombard Street blends romance with economic history, according to Kirkus, which describes the research as clever and the result as a delight. The Avon Books novel receives one rave and two positive reviews.
Nuzo Onoh’s The Turning of Sally-Mae, published by Titan Books, receives one positive and two mixed reviews. Library Journal recommends it to readers of V. Castro’s The Queen of the Cicadas and LaTanya McQueen’s When the Reckoning Comes.
Nonfiction: overlooked figures and private lives
Lindsey Fitzharris’s Sleuth-Hound: The Case of the Real Sherlock Holmes tops the nonfiction list with two rave and four positive reviews. The Farrar, Straus and Giroux book restores Dr. Joseph Bell to the Holmes story as the model for Arthur Conan Doyle’s detective, a connection Booklist reviewer David Pitt says the book makes clear.
Lawrence Wright’s Redemption: Faith, Justice, and Sisterhood on Death Row earns three rave, one positive and one mixed review. Published by Knopf, the book profiles prisoners and nuns, with attention to guilt, justice and personal change. The Boston Globe’s Kate Tuttle calls it one of Wright’s most personal works of journalism and praises its richly observed portraits.
Cartoonist Lisa Hanawalt’s I Can’t Stop Thinking about Horses and Sex, from Drawn and Quarterly, receives three rave and one positive review. Its comic vignettes and vivid animal drawings carry a more serious account of the author’s inner life. In The New York Times Book Review, Sam Thielman praises Hanawalt’s precise, candid treatment of subjects she might otherwise hide.
Zaina Arafat’s Our Arab: On Longing, Belonging, and Hope earns two rave and one positive review. Publishers Weekly describes the Little, Brown and Company book as a powerful examination of the wounded hearts of Palestinians in exile.
Blake J. Harris’s Emperor of Nothing: The Making of Larry David rounds out the list with three positive and one mixed review. The Dey Street Books biography traces the creation and development of David’s two major television comedies. A Wall Street Journal review finds Harris’s account lively and intimate, while observing that it leans toward admiration and gives little space to David’s romantic history.
Together, the week’s reviews favor books that look closely at how people shape—and are shaped by—friendship, family, work and public identity.