Movies

Idris Elba Nearly Played Deathstroke Before James Gunn Chose Bloodsport

2026-11-03 00:00
949 views

James Gunn considered Idris Elba for Deathstroke in The Suicide Squad before Joe Manganiello’s prior casting helped steer the role toward Bloodsport.

How Bloodsport took shape

Idris Elba’s Bloodsport was built to fill a gap in The Suicide Squad—and, for a time, James Gunn considered making him Deathstroke instead. That casting detour helps explain how the film arrived at a character with little history in the team’s comics, while giving Elba a role that echoed the function of Will Smith’s Deadshot. The choice also shows how a franchise film can be shaped by practical limits as much as by a director’s first ideas: the character had to fit the story, the cast, and an existing screen continuity.

Smith wasn’t available to return as Deadshot, his assassin from 2016’s Suicide Squad. Early reports said Elba would take over the role in the 2021 sequel, but Elba and Gunn didn’t want him to replace Smith. That distinction matters: a direct recasting could have made the sequel feel like it was simply continuing Deadshot’s story with a new face, while a separate character let Elba establish his own place in the ensemble.

Bloodsport became the alternative: a Superman antagonist known for firing Kryptonite bullets, with a brief nod to that history in his film rap sheet. The reference gives comic readers a line back to the character’s source material without requiring the film to build its plot around Superman. Bloodsport also occupies familiar story territory, leading the squad and having a daughter, Tyla (Storm Reid), in a setup that recalls Deadshot’s daughter, Zoe Lawton. The parallels make the role legible to audiences who remember the earlier film, even as the character’s name and history differ.

The casting choice came into focus during a DC podcast about whether The Suicide Squad belongs to the franchise’s canon. The film was made for the now-defunct DC Extended Universe; Gunn has since become DC Studios co-head and launched a new DC Universe. In the podcast, “The Suicide Squad: Is It Canon?”, Gunn appeared with actors Jennifer Holland and Steve Agee and discussed the film’s place in that changing continuity. The question is more than a matter of labels: where a film sits in a franchise can affect whether its characters and storylines are available for later use.

Why Deathstroke didn’t make the cut

Gunn said the Deathstroke idea ended after Elba requested a different character. Gunn thought Elba may have noticed negative reactions to the prospect of replacing Smith. Some concept art for the film nevertheless shows Deathstroke leading the squad, evidence that the idea got beyond a passing thought. Concept art doesn’t establish how far the plan progressed, but it does make clear that Deathstroke was considered as a visual and story option.

There was another complication: Joe Manganiello had already been cast as Slade Wilson in the DCEU. He appeared in the post-credits scene of Justice League, which pointed toward Deathstroke as the antagonist in Ben Affleck’s planned, but never made, Batman film. Gunn said Manganiello asked him not to use the character, and Gunn dropped the idea to avoid taking the role away from his friend. With Deadshot and Deathstroke out, Bloodsport became the fit.

That sequence of decisions gives the character’s place in the film a practical explanation. Bloodsport wasn’t simply chosen because he was the most obvious comic-book counterpart to Deadshot; he gave Gunn room to preserve the squad’s familiar shape while avoiding two casting conflicts. Here's the thing: a lesser-known character can be useful precisely because a film has more room to define him. The trade-off is that the movie must do more work to establish why viewers should care.

Gunn said he likes Bloodsport and would like to see Elba return, either in that role or as someone else. That leaves the possibility open without signaling an active plan. “I like Bloodsport so much. I'd like to see the character return,” Gunn said. “I also like working with Idris. Idris is a good guy, so I would like to see him return as Bloodsport or even somebody else.” A warm expression of interest is not a production announcement, and Gunn’s comments don’t identify a project or timetable.

Deathstroke’s next screen prospects

Deathstroke, meanwhile, remains in the mix for DC’s future. Reports in 2024 described a team-up film pairing him with Batman villain Bane, and by October 2026 the project, titled Savage Hunters, had reportedly become a DC Studios priority. The studio is also reportedly developing a Teen Titans movie, a property with a direct connection to Deathstroke’s comic-book origins. Those reports create possible routes for the character, but they don’t confirm that he’ll appear in either project.

For a character whose screen plans have been discussed in connection with more than one unmade film, that distinction matters. Announced or reported development can change, and a project’s status doesn’t guarantee a particular actor, storyline, or release. If you're working in this space, the useful signal is that DC’s reported plans keep Deathstroke in circulation; the less certain part is what form his return might take. A possibility, not a promise.

Manganiello’s return as the character appears unlikely. In a 2024 interview with ComicBook.com, he said Gunn advised him to “let it go”—a reference to the Deathstroke plans he had developed. Elba’s near-casting adds a revealing footnote: Bloodsport emerged from a crowded set of constraints, while Deathstroke’s next appearance now depends on a different chapter of DC’s screen plans. And yet the story also shows how quickly a character’s apparent future can shift when a franchise changes direction.

What the casting detour says about DC’s plans

This is more significant than it looks. Bloodsport’s creation for the film wasn’t just a substitution on a cast list; it helped preserve the ensemble’s central dynamic while giving Elba a distinct identity within it. At the same time, the film’s history makes clear that comic-book familiarity doesn’t automatically decide who gets used. Existing actors, past plans, and the needs of a particular story can all shape the choice.

For viewers, the practical takeaway is modest: Bloodsport’s resemblance to Deadshot reflects a deliberate story function, while his comic-book identity gives him a separate history. Deathstroke’s concept art and Manganiello’s earlier casting show that Gunn considered another path, but neither guarantees what DC will do next. The numbers here are underwhelming in the sense that no firm return for Elba is on the table in Gunn’s comments. What remains is a useful snapshot of how one franchise decision can leave two characters with very different screen prospects.

Source: [email protected] (Devin Meenan) · www.slashfilm.com