At Festival America, American writers brought an unsparing account of their country to a French audience: democracy under strain, enduring racism, economic inequality and a justice system they described as broken. The gathering in Vincennes drew crowds for difficult conversations about the United States’ past and present, with many authors treating criticism as an expression of attachment rather than rejection.
A festival built around hard questions
Sixty prominent U.S. authors with recent French translations took part in the 12th biennial Festival America, held September 24–27. Across nearly 100 sessions, writers including Ta-Nehisi Coates, John Grisham and Barbara Kingsolver addressed the country’s divisions and its democratic ideals.
The program made the emphasis plain. Sessions included “The American Dream: Reality or Illusion?,” “The Memory of Slavery,” “The Other America,” on the genocide of Native Americans, and “USA, Fade to Black,” on widespread violence. The Saturday night event “The Wounds of America,” featuring Viet Thanh Nguyen, Tommy Orange and Jesmyn Ward, sold out within an hour of tickets going online.
There were also discussions of writing, love and family, and those drew audiences too. But the festival’s major programs focused on history and current anxieties. The timing gave those debates added weight: France was approaching a consequential election of its own, though the protests that would later turn violent had not yet begun when the authors met in September.
Criticism as a form of commitment
Festival founder and president Francis Geffard, a publisher at Albin Michel, rejected the idea that the event put America on trial. He described it instead as an expression of French concern for a country whose history is closely entangled with France’s.
“America’s past is in some ways our past. Your problems are our problems,” Geffard said. Discussions of colonialism and racism, he added, prompt French audiences to examine their own history: “Everything you look at always comes back to you.” He also described a French “love and fascination” with America, saying that such feeling makes people “exigent”—demanding, in the sense he intended, and urgent.
Memoirist Sasha Bonét offered a similar account of the writers’ impulse during a Sunday morning discussion on democracy. “I love America so much, and like [James] Baldwin said, it’s why I am so critical of her,” she said.
Bonét framed writing as a way to challenge the stories a country tells about itself: “What I think about when I sit down to write is how can I help to reveal the lies that have been told, expose what’s been erased.” American writers, she told the audience, are “on the job,” offering truth-telling through literature.
Other speakers pointed to political and economic fault lines. In a discussion of justice, Patrick Radden Keefe said graft and corruption—once morally repugnant across political lines—had become “basically baked in.” Debut novelist Addie E. Citchens, speaking in “Where Will America Go?,” argued that the country’s divisions were driven by what she called “green people”: “the Epstein class. It’s them and us. And they have a vested interest in people not being unified.”
French audiences, American literature
The festival’s reception points to the place books hold in French public life. Thomas Chatterton Williams, an American author who spends much of each year in France, has attended numerous literary festivals there. “You get crowds all over the country for writers who are not even French…. In France, books matter,” he said.
Festival America is funded largely by French public bodies and municipalities, which also support hundreds of other literary festivals across the country. The U.S. Embassy in Paris had backed the event since its founding 24 years earlier, after the September 11 attacks. But shortly after the festival program was announced in late August, the Embassy withdrew its funding.
The festival said the contribution had been small, but described the support as a partnership grounded in culture, ideas and longstanding ties between the two countries. It deplored what it called “this striking lack of regard for American literature.” Geffard was saddened by the decision, but said the festival would continue: “But it’s fine, it’s fine.”
The gathering took place before protests against the concentration of wealth and power spread through Paris and turned violent. Its discussions had already put inequality and democratic strain at the center of the program. Festival America’s clearest message was that American writers intend to keep examining those problems—and that French readers are willing to listen.
Cherilyn Parsons is the founder and former director of Bay Area Book Festival. She lives in Paris.