Witnesses and public memory
Clint Smith’s forthcoming book on World War II starts from a narrowing window: the people who remember the conflict firsthand are nearing the end of their lives. In Just Beneath the Soil: World War II Through the Eyes of Its Last Witnesses, due from Knopf in May 2027, Smith pairs their accounts with visits to monuments, memorials, and other places that shape public memory. The pairing gives the project two kinds of evidence to consider: what people recall living through, and what communities choose to preserve in public. Each can reveal something the other can’t.
The project grew from questions raised by his bestselling 2021 book, How the Word Is Passed: A Reckoning with the History of Slavery Across America, which examined how sites across the United States confront—or avoid—the history of slavery. During that book’s tour, conversations about American memory repeatedly turned to Germany’s treatment of the Holocaust. Smith traveled there in 2021 and 2022 to see how that history is told, and began reading more broadly about the war. The route from one subject to another reflects a question that runs through both projects: how does a society decide which parts of its past deserve public attention, and what happens to the parts it leaves out?
That research changed Smith’s sense of what he knew. Germany became an entry point to accounts from people and places beyond the familiar “Band of Brothers framework,” he said. The new book, he explained, considers both public sites of remembrance and the survivors whose experiences give those sites human meaning. A memorial can establish what a community wants visitors to remember; a witness can complicate that account with the realities of individual experience. This is more significant than it looks: remembrance can become abstract when it’s separated from the people whose lives give it weight.
Smith is also interested in what disappears when those witnesses are gone. He asked what their passing might mean for society and for the political order that took shape after World War II. In his view, the loss of people able to describe how destructive events can become may help explain the weakening of that postwar structure. That’s a question about the uses of memory as much as memory itself: whether firsthand testimony changes how later generations understand the institutions built in response to war. The book’s premise rests on the possibility that testimony carries a force that monuments and history books alone can’t reproduce.
Teaching history in full
Smith will address attendees at the NCTE Secondary Section Luncheon on November 21. His message to educators draws on his years as a high school English teacher: students need history presented with complexity, nuance, and room for the many accounts that shape a nation and the wider world. That approach asks students to sit with competing experiences instead of treating the past as a neat sequence of lessons with one obvious point. For teachers, it also means making space for evidence and interpretation, not just the most familiar names and episodes.
He worries that public arguments about the past can reduce it to a narrow set of stories—or remove some stories from view altogether. In his account, history is sometimes selected to serve present-day political aims, with attention focused on a limited group of white, American, or European figures. The problem isn’t simply that some people receive more attention than others. A restricted account can leave students with a distorted sense of who shaped events and whose experiences count as part of a shared history.
Smith wants teachers to resist turning history and education into ideological tools. Students, he said, should encounter the “both/andedness” of national and world history. When people from the past appear as complicated, inconsistent human beings, students have more ways to recognize themselves in those lives. A person can belong to a historical moment and still resist its expectations, just as a nation can contain ideals and failures at once. That kind of teaching leaves room for judgment without flattening the people being judged.
Still an educator
Smith says he misses the classroom constantly. Teaching high school English, he recalled, was the best job he had, especially the experience of discussing literature with teenagers. He can imagine an alternate life spent teaching for decades. The memory suggests that education isn’t just a subject he writes about; it remains a model for how he wants readers to meet difficult material. In a classroom, understanding grows through questions and conversation, not only through the authority of a finished account.
He also sees how much the work asks of teachers. In the years since Covid, social media and AI have become widespread, while educators face challenges affecting students both inside and outside school. Smith says friends in teaching remain devoted to their work but are often exhausted. Those pressures shape what teachers can take on, and what support students may need as they encounter subjects that are emotionally demanding or contested. Here’s the thing: a call for richer teaching has to reckon with the conditions in which teachers are asked to do it.
That experience still shapes Smith’s writing. He aims for How the Word Is Passed and Just Beneath the Soil to work in high school American and world history classes, combining accessibility with scholarly rigor. His Crash Course Black American History YouTube series likewise grew from a desire to give teachers resources for teaching the Black American experience. The common thread is an effort to make complex history usable in classrooms without sanding off the complexity that makes it worth teaching. For a book built around witnesses and public memory, that balance will matter: readers need context, but they also need the voices and contradictions that resist easy summary.
What remains after the witnesses
For Smith, writing and teaching share a purpose: opening doors to history, language, poetry, and human experience. His new book extends that classroom impulse to a subject whose living witnesses are becoming harder to find. If you’re working in education, the project’s central question reaches beyond World War II: what can students learn from testimony while it’s still possible to hear it directly, and how should that testimony be carried forward afterward? (And this is the part most people overlook.) Preserving a story means deciding how to present it, not simply keeping a record.
That work won’t end when the last eyewitnesses are gone. It’ll depend on how later generations read their accounts, interpret memorials, and make room for perspectives that don’t fit a single national story. The tension between preserving memory and arguing over its meaning is part of the subject. No tidy answer.