Why some celebrity costumes outlast Halloween
Most celebrity Halloween looks disappear from the feed within days. The ones that stick are often the ones that turn a costume into a public argument. This list focuses on 14 outfits that drew criticism from other celebrities, and the first two show why context can matter as much as the clothes.
When a costume invokes real violence
Julia Fox’s 2025 look as Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis made a painful piece of history impossible to ignore: she wore a pink suit and pillbox hat marked with blood, evoking Kennedy’s appearance after President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in 1963. Online critics called the outfit “tasteless” and “inappropriate.” Jack Schlossberg, Jackie and JFK’s grandson, joined the criticism. In a post on X, he wrote: “Julia Fox glorifying political violence is disgusting, desperate and dangerous. I'm sure her late grandmother would agree.” Fox’s explanation, shared on Instagram, framed the outfit as a statement rather than a costume. She said Jackie Kennedy had refused to change out of her bloodstained clothes after the assassination, quoting her as saying, “I want them to see what they've done.” Fox described the pink suit as a haunting collision of beauty and horror, and Kennedy’s choice as bravery, protest, mourning, and a way to expose brutality. She concluded that femininity can be resistance, signing off: “Long live Jackie O. ♥️” That defense explains Fox’s intent, but it doesn’t settle the dispute. The same image can read as a tribute to Kennedy’s defiance or as an aesthetic treatment of political violence. Schlossberg’s response made clear that, for the family, the latter interpretation carried real weight.When the industry sets costume rules
Megan Fox and her then-partner, Machine Gun Kelly, chose characters from Kill Bill for Halloween in 2023: Fox went as Gogo Yubari, while Kelly dressed as the Bride. On their own, the outfits might seem like straightforward film fandom. The timing changed the stakes. The SAG-AFTRA and WGA strikes were underway, and the actors’ union had asked members not to dress as characters from struck productions. Its stated reason was to avoid promoting those titles without a fair contract and to “use our collective power to send a loud and clear message to our struck employers.” The union suggested costumes based on generalized characters and figures instead. If you’re working in entertainment, that episode is a reminder that even a playful personal choice can become a labor issue when it carries a studio’s intellectual property into public view. Fox and Kelly’s costumes drew attention because the broader context was hard to miss. The available details don’t explain whether they considered the union guidance or why they chose those characters. The contrast is the point: a look can be harmless in isolation and contentious in the moment it appears.By Kristen Harris, BuzzFeed Staff. Harris writes about celebrities, pop culture, and books. Published Oct. 30, 2026 UTC.
Megan Fox’s costume post drew a union rebuke
SAG-AFTRA had asked members not to share social media photos of costumes based on struck productions. Megan Fox posted hers anyway—and tagged the union. That choice turned a Halloween photo into a public dispute over what solidarity during the strike should look like. The union’s guidance was reported by The Hollywood Reporter; Fox’s since-deleted post was captured by Pop Crave.

Lisa Ann Walter, the Abbott Elementary actor and a member of SAG-AFTRA’s negotiating committee, responded sharply. “What a rebel. Keep posturing for stupid shit, pretty lady,” she wrote, pointing to the unpaid ten-hour workdays committee members were putting in to secure a fair deal for lower-paid union members. She later listed the issues she said the union was fighting for: turnaround rules, relocation fees, AI protections and streaming residuals. Her point was that the union’s work benefits people who can’t negotiate those terms on their own.
Walter also explained to Page Six that tagging the union was what angered her. “Her adding the union on that day, that was the flip-off,” she said, calling the gesture “bratty.” But Walter had never met Fox, said she was likely “lovely,” and apologized for the dispute becoming such a big deal. Fox and Machine Gun Kelly never publicly responded.

North West and Natalie Nunn turned a costume into a joke between them
The backlash didn’t always come from the person being impersonated. In 2026, North West, the 13-year-old daughter of Kim Kardashian and Kanye West, dressed as Baddies star Natalie Nunn, using prosthetics to exaggerate Nunn’s chin. Online commenters called the look mean-spirited and criticized Kardashian’s parenting. The criticism was real, but Nunn herself appeared to take the costume in stride. Here’s the story behind it.

Nunn reposted one of North’s videos on Instagram, saying she’d get North a “baddie chain” and wishing her a happy Halloween month. Then Nunn reversed the joke by dressing up as North. North’s response was brief: “omg.”

A Katy Perry costume sparked a rumor about Orlando Bloom
Rachel Matthews, the Happy Death Day actor, recreated Katy Perry’s astronaut outfit from the singer’s viral 11-minute Blue Origin trip to space with Jeff Bezos. By chance, Matthews ran into Perry’s ex-fiancé, Orlando Bloom, while wearing it. She posted a photo with Bloom to her Instagram Story and captioned it, “will tell my kids about this one day.” The costume and the encounter were genuine; the romantic implication that followed was not supported by the post.

A Katy Perry fan account recast Matthews as Bloom’s “new gf” in a viral tweet. The claim was debunked, and Matthews’ caption reads more like a fan enjoying an unlikely encounter than a hint at a relationship. Still, the rumor spread. That’s the familiar internet move: turn a coincidence into a storyline, then let the storyline outrun the evidence.
Kayla Nicole’s Toni Braxton tribute had a story behind it
The clip looked to some viewers like a pointed message to Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift. Kayla Nicole had dated Kelce for five years, and Swift’s fans had previously harassed her online simply because she was his ex. But the backstory she later shared makes the Halloween post a much less straightforward bit of celebrity gossip.
In 2025, Nicole dressed as Toni Braxton in the “He Wasn’t Man Enough” video and posted herself dancing to the song on Instagram. The lyrics include a sharp exchange about an ex who left one woman for another, which helps explain why commenters read the performance as a “petty” dig. That interpretation spread quickly. It also wasn’t the explanation Nicole gave.
On The Pre-Game, Nicole said the costume drew on a childhood memory of a friend named Taylor. Her friend was white, and Nicole recalled riding home from private school with her in a paddy wagon while Taylor’s mother played Braxton’s song. The moment gave young Nicole an “a-ha” realization: “Wow, white people listen to Black people music as well.”
Nicole later addressed the speculation again, saying the post had nothing to do with Kelce or Swift. She described Halloween as a chance to “let your creative flag fly,” and said she wanted to celebrate an icon in her culture, not tear down another woman.
That explanation doesn’t erase why people saw the lyrics through the lens of her past relationship. But the online reaction shows how quickly a personal reference can get swallowed by a celebrity narrative—especially when an ex has already been targeted by a fanbase. Nicole’s account gives the costume a more ordinary, and more personal, origin.