Louise Penny’s 21st book, Miss Wolcott’s Ghost, draws on the life of a Victorian botanist whose work slipped from public memory. The novel, published October 20 by Minotaur, arrives as Penny continues to weigh the costs of her decision to skip U.S. tour dates—and returns to the questions of compassion and forgiveness that run through her Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series.
Speaking from Montreal, Penny joked that a 21-book career was “old enough to drink.” She gave up alcohol long ago, though, so launch parties won’t be an occasion to raise a glass. The conversation with PW ranged from the politics behind her tour boycott to the spiritual ideas that shape Gamache, and the unexpected uses she has found for her success.
A tour decision with a cost
Penny skipped U.S. stops for her previous book, Black Wolf, amid the tariff dispute and increasingly hostile cross-border rhetoric. She said her decision stands, even though she has a home in New York, close friends in the United States and deep affection for the country.
“This isn't something Canada ever wanted, but it's more than willing to stand up for itself,” she said. Returning, she suggested, may depend on more than tariffs easing: “Is this about other things I find morally reprehensible?” The situation has been “shocking and very sad,” she said, and she isn’t sure what would need to change before she tours there again.
The choice has had a business cost. Penny said that not touring affects book sales, and she acknowledged that readers who disagree with her may not buy her books. “It would be childish to take a stand and not expect that,” she said. Her U.S. publisher has supported her and, she said, has never asked whether she would return to tour.
Kindness shaped by pain
Gamache’s decency, and the series’ recurring interest in redemption, don’t come from a simple belief in goodness. Penny said the detective, like many people, “had to be hurt into his decency.” She connected the idea to W. H. Auden’s elegy for Yeats, which includes the line “mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.”
Her husband, Michael, also shaped her thinking about the moral choices in the books. He believed that “the courage to be kind takes so much more courage than cruelty,” Penny said. That conviction informs the series’ violence: “In my books, it's harder not to pull the trigger than to pull the trigger.”
The spiritual and humanist themes in her fiction aren’t a campaign to convert readers, she said. Penny described herself as neither anti-church nor interested in telling others what to believe. She lives in Quebec, a province that “turned its back on religion for good reason,” and said Gamache doesn’t need an institution to guide his moral life.
A recent appearance with the Archbishop of Sweden brought home how closely religious texts sit alongside those themes. The archbishop pointed out that Penny had quoted Matthew 10:36 on a particular page; she recalled thinking, “oh no, I got that wrong.” The moment is part of a wider interest in faith, rather than an appeal for readers to share hers.
Finding Ellen Willmott
Penny came across botanist Ellen Willmott while researching at a London gardening museum. Willmott was an eccentric Victorian figure whose work was often labeled “amateur,” Penny said, though she accomplished things that professionals didn’t dare attempt.
The book’s title refers to Miss Willmott’s Ghost, a plant Willmott reportedly slipped into the gardens of prominent neighbors. Penny liked the gesture’s mix of horticulture and mischief: “a kind of guerrilla warfare.” She said her historical research feels less like a deliberate search for overlooked figures and more like being “a child in a candy shop.”
Success put to work
Penny said she loves writing the Gamache books and can’t imagine stopping. The success of the series has also enabled the Three Pines Foundation, established in Michael’s memory. It supports dementia care, literacy and other causes, including small grants to people facing immediate hardship.
“I can't fund a school or a hospital wing,” she said. Instead, the foundation helps an older person struggling to pay an electricity bill or a family whose breadwinner has been diagnosed with cancer. “It doesn't take much to make a difference: a couple thousand here, a hundred there.”
Michael, a pediatric oncologist, died in 2016 after a long battle with dementia. Penny said his work showed him both how difficult life can be and “what a great gift life is.” Her takeaway is practical: for those fortunate enough to live it, decency is a responsibility.
Geoff Koch is a writer and poet in Portland, Ore.