Celebrities

Diana Reid’s ‘Sense and Sensibility’ Puts the Dashwood Sisters First

2026-10-29 00:00
667 views

Screenwriter Diana Reid recasts Austen’s romance around the bond between Elinor and Marianne, with changes that make the story speak to modern audiences.

For Diana Reid, the clearest way to make a new Sense and Sensibility was to shift the focus from the sisters’ romantic prospects to the relationship shaping them both. Her screenplay brings Elinor and Marianne Dashwood’s bond to the foreground, treating sisterhood as the story’s engine rather than a subplot to the romances.

That emphasis gives Reid a distinct point of entry into a novel adapted repeatedly for film and television. Emma Thompson’s 1995 version, starring Hugh Grant and Kate Winslet, is often regarded as definitive. Reid, a novelist who has long admired Jane Austen’s wit and insight into character, says her rereading of the book revealed how much of its action and emotional growth comes from the sisters’ love for each other.

The new film stars Daisy Edgar-Jones as Elinor and Esmé Creed-Miles as Marianne, whose contrasting approaches to love test and teach them. Reid spoke with PW about bringing Austen’s humor to the screen, reshaping parts of the story, and making the sisters’ influence on each other central.

Sisterhood as a coming-of-age story

Reid doesn’t have a sister, but she sees sisterhood as a bond that extends beyond siblings. In a coming-of-age story, she says, a woman’s identity takes shape through her relationships with other women: what she learns from them, and how they challenge one another. That dynamic, in her view, is familiar to many women and helps explain why Austen’s work continues to resonate.

Her reading also informs the film’s ending. The final frame shows Elinor and Marianne embracing. Their expressions, Reid says, convey gratitude for what each has taught the other. It’s a quiet image, but it gathers the film’s emotional argument into one moment: the sisters’ relationship has changed them, and endures beyond the turns of their love lives.

Keeping Austen’s wit—and its emotional turns

Reid singled out two lines she wanted to preserve. One is comic: after a difficult night at a ball and an argument with Marianne, Elinor declares, “I will drink the wine myself.” Reid likes the line’s unexpectedly modern feel. The production considered cutting it because its bottle-draining beat might evoke Bridget Jones, but Austen wrote it into the novel. Reid sees the joke as proof of the author’s knack for making characters feel immediate.

The other passage gives Elinor a much more delicate reckoning with love. Reid moved the moment when Elinor says, “Although it is bewitching, the idea that one’s happiness depends on another person, it is not meant—it is not fit—it is not always possible.” For Reid, the sentence briefly sounds like a moral verdict against making romance the center of one’s life. Then Elinor falters before she can fully reject love, settling instead on the possibility that it may not happen for her.

Reid credits the passage with compressing a psychological shift into a few words. Daisy Edgar-Jones’s performance, she says, preserves the tension: Elinor accepts uncertainty without quite surrendering the hope of love.

Adapting the story for the screen

Reid rejects the idea that fidelity means reproducing every detail. A novel and a film have different tools, she argues, so an adaptation may need to change events while holding on to the original’s themes. In Austen’s book, a duel between two characters is mentioned but never staged. Reid brought it onto the screen, where the action lets viewers see which man Marianne supports—and makes her shifting affections visible.

Some changes address a different gap: the distance between Austen’s social world and modern audience expectations. Reid points to Colonel Brandon’s original backstory. In the novel, he is 36, Marianne is 16, and he has a daughter the same age as Marianne. Reid says that arrangement was not treated as shocking when Austen wrote it, but would now read as paternalistic and unsettling. The film changes Brandon’s history rather than asking viewers to accept that age dynamic as unremarkable.

These choices reflect Reid’s broader approach: preserve the emotional force of Austen’s characters while finding screen language and context that let contemporary viewers read them clearly. In her version, that work comes into focus in the final embrace. The sisters’ romantic stories matter, but their lasting influence on one another is the film’s defining image.

Source: By Marisa Charpentier · www.publishersweekly.com